Let's make an all-star band..... (Full Version)

All Forums >> [Fun] >> Music



Message

Biblefreak -> Let's make an all-star band..... (4/1/2008 3:30:18 PM)

I thought this would be kind of cool. Let's put the parts in place to create a "Super group."

I'll start on drums.....


http://youtube.com/watch?v=NuOTkrEVeb4&feature=related

http://youtube.com/watch?v=q-BRee2bAho


The great Neil Pert!!!!



nealmorsefan -> RE: Let's make an all-star band..... (4/1/2008 7:42:33 PM)

quote:


The great Neil Pert!!!!


You're joking, right? You do realize this is Crosswalk Forums, right? If you want to put together a secular super group, I suggest Yahoo Answers or Google Community. This is not to say Neil Pert is not worthy of being included in a super group, because he probably is. I just don't see the point of propping up secular artists when it will inevitably lead to players like Flea (Red Hot Chili Peppers), Slash (GNR), and maybe even Marilyn Manson. We don't need that here.

So...as a suggestion for a drummer from the Christian realm, I submit the name Jon Knox (Adam Again/White Heart).

Then, for the next suggestion, I'll logically move to bassist and submit the name Bil Brown (Dig Hay Zoose).

Next...



PHmosh1 -> RE: Let's make an all-star band..... (4/2/2008 7:43:01 AM)

I have 2 guitar player suggestions.

Phil Keagy & that guy who used to play in White Cross (I forget his name)



uncabeeil -> RE: Let's make an all-star band..... (4/2/2008 12:39:57 PM)

Drums: Chester Thompson (Genesis' touring drummer)
Bass: Bernard Harris
Lead & Acoustic Guitars: Phil Keaggy
Steel Guitar: Robert Randolph
Keys: Michael O'Martian
Vocals: Elvis Presley, Twila Paris



DaveW -> RE: Let's make an all-star band..... (4/4/2008 12:58:38 PM)

Is this a secular or christian band? Rock, pop or jazz?

for the christian rock group:

Phil Keaggy on guitar
Glen Schwartz on guitar (Pacific Gas & Electric, GS and the All Saved Freak Band)
John Mehler (LoveSong) on drums
John DeGroff (original Petra) on bass
Rick Wakeman (Yes, solo) on keys (yes - he is a believer!)



iluvatar -> RE: Let's make an all-star band..... (4/4/2008 9:26:05 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: nealmorsefan

quote:


The great Neil Pert!!!!


You're joking, right? You do realize this is Crosswalk Forums, right? If you want to put together a secular super group, I suggest Yahoo Answers or Google Community. This is not to say Neil Pert is not worthy of being included in a super group, because he probably is. I just don't see the point of propping up secular artists when it will inevitably lead to players like Flea (Red Hot Chili Peppers), Slash (GNR), and maybe even Marilyn Manson. We don't need that here.


You're new here, aren't you?

Vocals: either Bruce Dickinson or Dio, maybe Geoff Tate if he was still 25yo.

If we're going the acoustic route, then Jerry Douglas on slide and Bella Fleck on banjo.

-Dan.



howling wind -> RE: Let's make an all-star band..... (4/5/2008 7:53:02 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: nealmorsefan

quote:


The great Neil Pert!!!!


You're joking, right? You do realize this is Crosswalk Forums, right? If you want to put together a secular super group, I suggest Yahoo Answers or Google Community. This is not to say Neil Pert is not worthy of being included in a super group, because he probably is. I just don't see the point of propping up secular artists when it will inevitably lead to players like Flea (Red Hot Chili Peppers), Slash (GNR), and maybe even Marilyn Manson. We don't need that here.

So...as a suggestion for a drummer from the Christian realm, I submit the name Jon Knox (Adam Again/White Heart).

Then, for the next suggestion, I'll logically move to bassist and submit the name Bil Brown (Dig Hay Zoose).

Next...


If the original poster wants to have secular artists listed, then let the guy have his say. Go start your own thread if you want to be so high and mighty.[8|]

As for bass players, I'd pick the guy who played for The Rezillos in the late 70's.



rockitd -> RE: Let's make an all-star band..... (4/7/2008 6:00:14 PM)

Drums: Louie Weaver (Petra)
Guitar: Rex Carroll (White Cross)
Bass: Tommy Simms (White Heart)
Keys: John Lawry (Petra)
Vocals:Michael Sweet (Stryper)



nealmorsefan -> RE: Let's make an all-star band..... (4/8/2008 12:42:42 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: howling wind
If the original poster wants to have secular artists listed, then let the guy have his say. Go start your own thread if you want to be so high and mighty.[8|]

As for bass players, I'd pick the guy who played for The Rezillos in the late 70's.


You didn't read my post, did you?

Sure, it's not a TOS violation, but the people who post here tend to be Christians because this is, after all, a Christian website...Crosswalk.com. If you are looking for opinions on the best collection of secular musicians into a single team, you might get more intelligent, experienced responses from a website that caters to secular music fans, don't ya think? Now, if you're looking for opinions from Christians on who are the best secular musicians to put together a super group, then fine. However, as much as I love Phil Keaggy, how many non-Christians are going to put his name up there for guitarist instead of Yngwie Malmsteen or Jimi Hendricks? Let's be honest, man. This would be somewhat like Oprah's magazine trying to assemble a list of the greatest women of all time simply by polling its readers...uh, who do you think would come in first? They would be better served polling readers of the New York Times, etc.

BTW...what was that avatar of yours that was banned?



nealmorsefan -> RE: Let's make an all-star band..... (4/8/2008 12:45:15 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: iluvatar

You're new here, aren't you?



Well, I have almost 300 posts. If that makes me "new" then so be it. Does that make my opinion less valid? Does that make my post any less correct? Don't think so.



uncabeeil -> RE: Let's make an all-star band..... (4/8/2008 12:51:55 PM)

quote:

Does that make my opinion less valid? Does that make my post any less correct? Don't think so.
No, but it makes your holier than thou, I'm right and you're wrong attitude that much more annoying.

And, as an FYI, if you're a true musician, you will have heard of Christian artists that play your instruments. Just because you choose to view life through a narrow tunnel doesn't mean everybody does. I knew who Phil Keaggy was 20 years before I got saved. Why? Because as a guitar fan I had read about him. Imagine that!



nealmorsefan -> RE: Let's make an all-star band..... (4/8/2008 1:04:14 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: uncabeeil

quote:

Does that make my opinion less valid? Does that make my post any less correct? Don't think so.
No, but it makes your holier than thou, I'm right and you're wrong attitude that much more annoying.

And, as an FYI, if you're a true musician, you will have heard of Christian artists that play your instruments. Just because you choose to view life through a narrow tunnel doesn't mean everybody does. I knew who Phil Keaggy was 20 years before I got saved. Why? Because as a guitar fan I had read about him. Imagine that!


Yes, but 20 years ago would you have put Phil Keaggy in your all-star band? I'm not saying he doesn't belong there, I'm making the point that this forum has a Christian bias and will favor artists like him. I'm all in favor of the Christian bias here, of course. It's the whole reason the website exists.

As for the "holier than thou" attitude. Have you heard of the apostle Paul? He said to be holy as he is holy. Do you despise him, too? Why is it bad to have standards?



howling wind -> RE: Let's make an all-star band..... (4/8/2008 1:05:24 PM)

quote:

You didn't read my post, did you?


No, I read your post and it confirmed my thoughts that you are very narrow-minded. The original poster mentioned Neil Peart, so I assume we could post secular musicians. If you want your own thread of "Christian musicians only", feel free to start it.

BTW, you are probably too holy to appreciate my last avatar...



nealmorsefan -> RE: Let's make an all-star band..... (4/8/2008 1:15:17 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: howling wind

No, I read your post and it confirmed my thoughts that you are very narrow-minded.



Well, narrow is the road that leads to life and broad the road that leads to destruction.

quote:


The original poster mentioned Neil Peart, so I assume we could post secular musicians.


True...his bad. That's why I was rebuking him, not you. But if you really want me to... [:D]

quote:


If you want your own thread of "Christian musicians only", feel free to start it.


I did one at one time. It must have expired because I don't see it listed in the threads anymore. For your benefit, though, I shall resurrect it.

quote:


BTW, you are probably too holy to appreciate my last avatar...


Undoubtedly! [:D]



hawknelsonismyfriend -> RE: Let's make an all-star band..... (4/8/2008 8:29:24 PM)

vocals: matt thiessen (relient K), Jason dunn (hawk nelson)
bass: dan biro (hawk nelson)
drums: yuri (mxpx)
keyboard: ronnie martin (joy electric)
guitasr: the guiatrists from anberlin



MusicianDad -> RE: Let's make an all-star band..... (4/8/2008 10:48:22 PM)

Michael Schenker!!!!! Yes, he's now a christian.

http://youtube.com/watch?v=1qP_OqOJ8ug



iluvatar -> RE: Let's make an all-star band..... (4/9/2008 1:32:14 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: nealmorsefan

quote:

ORIGINAL: iluvatar

You're new here, aren't you?



Well, I have almost 300 posts. If that makes me "new" then so be it. Does that make my opinion less valid? Does that make my post any less correct? Don't think so.


It doesn't make it any more or less correct, but it does make it a little more surprising that in the time you've spent here, you had observed neither the surprisingly eclectic music tastes of some of the regulars here nor their abhorence of legalistic attitudes towards music.

-Dan.



DethWolf -> RE: Let's make an all-star band..... (4/9/2008 11:58:27 PM)

Dave Mustaine-Guitar and vocals
Dimebag Darrel-Guitar
Jason Newstead-Bass
Tommy Lee-Drums



shemaromans -> RE: Let's make an all-star band..... (4/10/2008 11:01:49 PM)

Drums--Mitch Mitchell



granolagirl -> RE: Let's make an all-star band..... (4/11/2008 10:10:23 AM)

There is already and all-star band. They are called Stavesacre. [sm=headphone.gif][sm=wink.gif][sm=tongue.gif]

This requires a lot of thought because you have to do what DethWolf did and pick guys/gals from the same genre. BTW I like DethWolf's picks.

My vote is for Neil Peart on drums also.



DethWolf -> RE: Let's make an all-star band..... (4/13/2008 7:02:49 PM)

Yeah. Also, I had this thought for one from some different genres:

Vocals:Joey Ramone
Guitar:Slash
Bass:Flea
Drums: Keith Moon



BarlowGuy25 -> RE: Let's make an all-star band..... (4/22/2008 6:17:02 PM)

Thought we had another thread.

Anyone as long as you have any of these WONDERFUL people:

bass: ALYSSA BARLOW
guitar: BECCA BARLOW
drums (especially!): LAUREN (ODIE) BARLOW

HOMER!!! Ramon, you're a HOMER!!

time for some Dove Love!!

(Oh, I and I can't believe someone mentioned Rush, just because I kinda find it coincidental...lately, I've thought of the Ladies Barlow as a kind of all-girl Rush (one of these so-called guitar-bass-drums "power trios"). Funny, but 'Lyssa plays both bass and keys, like Geddy Lee does.)



Page: [1]



Forum Software © ASPPlayground.NET Advanced Edition 2.5 ANSI